In the debate about the problem with file sharing, we have probably forgotten a very important aspect of the problem, the fact that teenagers can’t get their favorite songs legally, unless a parent is helping them.
This is what I believe was spotify strength and must, because Spotify is only the music service that kids could use themselves to find new music from the internet, or download illegal, where the parents stands legally responsible for the children crime on the web.
When Spotify removed Bob Dylan and some other tracks, I believe Spotify are crystalized to a service for independent music and labels, and teen pop, and this is because the payment weakness that those listner has.
The traditional music industry is probably commiting an real suicide, if they can’t change their minds. They probably tried to blew their listners to payment by attending spotify and then unattend it, which hazard the conflict additional.
I really think there is a very big capitalism inside the commercial music industry. The big monsters has nevered did something good, neither for the artists or their listners. Instead, their goal was primarly to manuafactor high environmental polluting compact discs, and their unwilling of being open for the development is a clear sign of immerse inside the labels.
Labels primary role is to invest in new talentens and making profit from them. They hijack the artists rights to their works and profit, leaving only about some few percent left to the artist iself.
It’s not a hard equation that we seen a real digital revolution, because the business role that the traditional industry are attempting to preserve are nearly outdate since many years ago.
The fact that the web are the absolutely best platform for musics and fans can not be disclosures. Sites such Jamendo, Record Union and other services enable new talent to make a avatar and a increditable fan base on a very short time, which previous only was preserved to the commercial radios.
Back to fact, many listners can’t, even if they wanted get their favorite music legally. Legal issues make it unpossible for minors to get their songs to their computer, even if they could pay, due to the need of a credit card.
We must let children get a moderate possibility to make payments iself at the web, as children can buy their ice-cream themselves at the beach. A system where special “child wallets” on web where only “child payment” approved payments could only be used with.
For example, what problem would it be if a child paid nine punds for their favorite album on the internet on a store, as they can buy a cd at the local store? To prevent security problems, and to save children economy, child payment should be maintained with an solution like paypal, where parents can set up a “web account” and define limitations on how children can use their money on the web. Additionally, to protect children, children can only pay on a web site which are trusted by the children payment system, and are strictly monitored by the child payment system.